[CR Note: Kathryn Casey has always been a favorite here on CR. Her true-crime books show off her great journalism skills and offer readers insight to the crimes most other TC authors simply just don’t. Today we’re celebrating the launch of her first mystery, SINGUALRITY and a new TC, A DESCENT INTO HELL. How does she find the time?]
Guest blog by Kathryn Casey
Cover true crime cases for a couple of decades and every once in awhile it happens: watch the news, read the paper, peruse the Internet, and wham! A news story catches your eye and you’re catapulted years back, maybe to New York, Oklahoma City, Los Angeles or Fort Lauderdale. It’s an odd sensation, kind of like that NBC show Journeyman. Let me explain.
It happened most recently last week. I was checking e-mail, when up popped a news story on 76-year-old Betty Johnson Neumar. Betty’s mug photo was darling, one of the cutest white-haired grandmas I’ve ever seen immortalized by a jail photographer. She even had on a black and white striped sweater, so fitting for prison.
Anyway, this sweet-looking old lady was under arrest for the 1986 murder of her fourth husband, Harold Gentry. Years ago, when the murder happened, there were reports that she’d tried to hire a hitman to gun Gentry down. One man even came forward and told police that she tried to pay him to commit the murder. Yet Betty wasn’t arrested. That might have been the end of the story except for Harold’s brother, Al Gentry, who wouldn’t let the case die. Year after year, he showed up at the Albem
arle, N.C., sheriff’s office talking about his brother’s murder and pointing at Betty. For 22 years, Al was ignored. Finally, fast forward, there’s a new sheriff in charge. After talking to Al and nosing around, Granny Betty is arrested and booked.
Then, more surprises. After her arrest, police learn that all five of Betty’s marriages have ended with a dead husband. There’s no info yet on husbands one or two, back in the fifties, but number three died of a bullet to the head. His death was ruled a suicide, but Betty was the only witness. (Convenient, don’t you think?) Perhaps not surprisingly, authorities are now testing the ashes of dead husband number five – who passed away in October 2007 – for arsenic.
So, to get back to my teleporting, there I was reading an article about Neumar when I flashed back thirteen years to 1995 and Steamboat Springs, Colorado.
It was March, snow everywhere, and I was investigating the case of Jill Coit for a magazine article. She was the Black Widow du jour. I call her that, obviously, because there always seems to be one of these babes out there, some woman, not unattractive, relatively bright, with an effervescent personality and a flair for style, who knows how to attract men and then, sigh, kills them and takes their money. In this case, Coit was on trial for murdering her tenth husband, Gerald Boggs, a hardware store owner.
As I circulated thr
ough the scenic ski town, I heard familiar refrains. This time they came from Boggs’s neighbors and friends, about how the lifetime bachelor had been hoodwinked by a manipulative and cunning woman, who used flattery and an air of needy vulnerability to reel him in. Coit cemented the relationship by pretending, although she’d had a hysterectomy years earlier, to be pregnant.
After Boggs found out Coit was still married to at least one previous husband, he had the marriage annulled. Guess she wasn’t ready to set the poor guy free, because not long after, along with Michael Backus, a new beau (You’re not surprised, are you?), Coit shot Boggs as he entered his home, then bludgeoned him with a shovel.
Just one dead husband? Nah. A couple of decades earlier, in 1972, Coit’s third husband, William Clark Coit, the father of two of her three sons, was found murdered in their Houston home. No one has ever been prosecuted, but many believed for decades that Jill was the culprit. Rumors circulated, as they did in the Neumar case, but no charges were ever brought.
With memories flooding back, I ran an Internet search on Coit, just to see what this black widow is up to, now that she’s serving a life sentence for murder. One would think that would shut her down. Maybe not.
It seems that even behind prison bars, our gal’s ingenuity and hope springs e
ternal. A brief search and I discovered that somehow Coit managed to open an Internet site from prison in 1998, to advertise for a new husband. Why would anyone marry this broad? Hey, Jill Coit understands the power of marketing. “Want U.S. citizenship? Marry an inmate!” she suggested. Once they found out, the Colorado Women’s Correctional Institute shut the website down.
Yup, reporting on crime cases for a couple of decades can be injurious to your health. Mental health that is. You begin to wonder if folks are ever going to wise up. You start thinking, heck, it’s how many years later and these conniving women are still reeling in one unsuspecting sap after another? Is this ever going to change?
Sadly, probably not.